Knit Dish: NY Style Crumb Cake

2012-11-09 13.01.27
I am so blaming my pregnancy on the fact that I am baking like it's my job. After my first pecan tart, I did a round of pumpkin cookies and many batches of chocolate chip cookies. I am even considering baking my way through Martha Stewart's Baking Handbook.

Recently, while we were in NJ we made a stop at my husband's house. His mother is a fabulous baker and you can tell that having been without power for 5 days she was aching to use her oven! A coffee cake and chocolate chip cake were already cooling on the counter and two more were baking when we arrived there the first day they got power back. All her baking got me in the mood to make some coffee cake of my own! 

What's funny is that I haven't been able to find my favorite Entemmann's coffee cake at any of our local supermarkets. You know the original crumb coffee cake. I'm not even talking about the "ultimate" one. I'm taking the plain ol' NY Style coffee cake (think Buttah!). It reminds me of post school afternoons and being at my grandmother's house. She always cut me a huge piece. I love that cake so much it even made an appearance at my after wedding party.

After doing a basic google search, I came across this recipe posted on the blog Smells Like Home. My first go around in baking the cake I did explicitly what they said not to do: use all purpose flour. I just didn't feel like going out at the time and preggo wanted some crumb cake!

Result: I am no bakery snob. (Well that's not ENTIRELY true. cough**tartine**cough) But I can honestly say that even using all purpose flour I still enjoyed the cake. I could see though that lacked some moistness and my crumbs were way too crumbly.

Well this morning after having gone out and apropriated some cake flour and dark brown sugar I gave it another go. A-HA!! Oh sweet mystery of life at last I found you!! (kudos to those who know that movie reference) Friends, do yourselves a favor – go out and get the friggin' cake flour. 

As a knitter I should have known, when you use materials not quite called for in the pattern it has the possibility of not coming out the way it should. Same apparently goes for baking. Perhaps it's why I love it so.

Now to figure out how to not get powdered sugar all over my handknits. (licks fingers)

7 thoughts on “Knit Dish: NY Style Crumb Cake

  1. Jillys says:

    That Entenmann’s cake was on my mom’s counter this morning and I nearly devoured the whole box! I could not find it on my last store visit either – LOVE it – the original!


  2. Melissa says:

    I have been searching in VAIN for a copy of said movie quoted above…not even at Halloween was I able to find a copy anywhere
    and I got confusion when I asked if it was in stock here, there and everywhere…’what movie are you looking for???’
    really!?!? you all are missing out…it’s a CLASSIC!
    your cake looks scrumptious!


  3. sonia says:

    saw that movie recently on netflix with our 10-year old. was worried he was a bit young, but nothing stood out as particularly likely to cause trauma. though for a few days he’d go around saying ‘schwanstuker’ and ‘he. vas. mein. boyfriend!’ more often than i would have preferred.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s